Opens in a new tab
Item 2

No password needed. When you want to sign in again, we will send you an email with a "magic link"

Item 1

RADYO SAGADA VERIFY: “Reclaiming land in Pasay by destroying the coastlines of Liwliwa, Zambales is not progress it’s environmental destruction. Dredging is killing marine life and wiping out coastal communities.”  NEEDS CONTEXT

Climate Change

CLAIM

“Reclaiming land in Pasay by destroying the coastlines of Liwliwa, Zambales is not progress it’s environmental destruction. Dredging is killing marine life and wiping out coastal communities.”

The statement was posted publicly on Facebook by Balai Maniago and links the reclamation of land in Pasay with coastal destruction in Liwliwa, Zambales.

VERDICT

NEEDS CONTEXT

The post is correct that sand dredging in Zambales has been used to supply at least one Pasay reclamation project. However, available government assessments do not establish that the dredging is the direct cause of Liwliwa’s coastal erosion, nor do they establish that dredging has already “killed marine life” or “wiped out coastal communities.”

There are legitimate environmental and livelihood concerns surrounding large-scale sand extraction, and affected residents and groups have called for further investigation. But the post presents the cause-and-effect relationship as settled when government assessments dispute it and more evidence is needed.

WHAT THE CLAIM SAYS

The Facebook post makes three connected claims:

  1. Pasay reclamation is being supplied by sand extracted from Zambales.
  2. That dredging is destroying the Liwliwa coastline.
  3. The dredging is killing marine life and destroying coastal communities.

The first claim is supported by official PRA records. The second and third require more qualification.


WHAT THE EVIDENCE SHOWS

1. Zambales sand has been used for Pasay reclamation

This part of the claim is supported by Philippine Reclamation Authority records.

The PRA says the 360-hectare Pasay Reclamation and Development Project commenced dredging at its sand source in Botolan, Zambales, in September 2021 after the project had completed the required conditions. (Pea)

The PRA also confirms that the 265-hectare Pasay Harbor City Reclamation Project is an ongoing reclamation project in Manila Bay. Actual reclamation works for the project began in November 2021. (Pea)

Therefore, it is accurate to say that Zambales has been used as a source of sand for a Pasay reclamation project.

However, this does not by itself prove that sand removed from Liwliwa’s coastline specifically was used for Pasay.


2. Dredging in Zambales is officially described as a river-desilting/restoration activity

Government records describe dredging activities in Zambales as involving heavily silted river channels, including the Bucao, Maloma and Santo Tomas river systems.

The government has said dredging vessels are supposed to remain within designated dredging zones rather than freely extracting sand along the Liwliwa beachfront. In September 2026, DENR Zambales said monitoring found no dredging vessels operating near Sitio Tektek in Liwliwa and said vessels were confined to designated areas in the Bucao and Santo Tomas systems. (Daily Tribune)

This distinction is important:

River dredging does not automatically the same thing as dredging the Liwliwa shoreline.


3. Liwliwa is experiencing serious coastal erosion

This part of the post is supported by evidence.

Reports from 2025 documented severe erosion in Liwliwa, with waves damaging or washing out resort structures. Residents and resort workers reported substantial livelihood losses. (GMA Network)

More recent reporting in September 2026 likewise documented seawater reaching properties in Liwliwa and damage to resorts following months of erosion. (Daily Tribune)

So there is no question that coastal erosion and its effects on local businesses and workers are real.


4. But MGB did not conclude that dredging caused the Liwliwa erosion

This is the most important missing context in the Facebook post.

The Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB) investigated the situation and said dredging was not the cause of the coastal erosion in Barangay Liwliwa.

According to MGB, erosion was already occurring before the dredging activities. The agency explained that much of the San Felipe coastline consists of accretion land formed from sediment deposited following the 1991 eruption of Mt. Pinatubo.

MGB also pointed to natural processes affecting the coastline, including sediment movement and wave action. (GMA Network)

A DENR report likewise described San Felipe’s historical shoreline growth as a result of coastal accretion, with lahar and sediments transported through river systems and subsequently moved along the shoreline by tides. (DENR)

This does not prove that dredging has zero environmental effect.

It means that the available government assessment does not support the stronger conclusion that dredging is the established direct cause of Liwliwa’s erosion.


5. Environmental concerns about large-scale sand extraction are legitimate

The Facebook post is also not baseless in raising environmental concerns.

The Philippine Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (PH-EITI) records a formal complaint concerning alleged sand mining disguised as river dredging in Zambales. The complaint was filed by the Zambales Ecological Network and affected communities, including fisherfolk and resort owners, who requested an independent review of environmental and social impacts. (PH-EITI)

Concerns raised include possible effects on:

  • sediment movement, coastal erosion,fisheries, biodiversity,fishing grounds, community livelihoods.

But these are concerns and issues requiring investigation, rather than proof that all the impacts alleged in the Facebook post have already been scientifically established.


WHAT IS TRUE

The following portions of the Facebook post are supported by available evidence:

  • Pasay has ongoing land reclamation projects. (Pea)
  • The PRA confirms that the Pasay 360 project used a sand source in Botolan, Zambales. (Pea)
  • Large-scale dredging operations have taken place in Zambales.
  • Liwliwa has experienced serious coastal erosion and damage to resort establishments. (Daily Tribune)
  • Fisherfolk, environmental groups and local communities have raised concerns about the ecological and livelihood effects of the dredging operations. (PH-EITI)
  • There are legitimate questions about the environmental consequences of removing large quantities of sediment from Zambales.

WHAT IS WRONG OR MISSING

The post overstates what the available evidence proves in several ways.

First, it establishes a connection but not causation.

The fact that sand from Zambales is used for Pasay reclamation does not prove that Pasay reclamation caused the erosion in Liwliwa.

Second, the post does not distinguish river dredging from shoreline dredging.

Government officials say the authorized dredging operations are confined to designated river channels and estuaries. (Daily Tribune)

Third, “dredging is killing marine life” is presented as an established fact.

Large-scale seabed or sediment extraction can potentially disturb marine ecosystems, but the specific claim that the Zambales operations have killed marine life in Liwliwa requires site-specific scientific evidence showing the extent and cause of the damage.

Fourth, “wiping out coastal communities” is too broad.

There is documented damage to resorts and livelihood disruption in Liwliwa. But saying that dredging has already “wiped out coastal communities” goes beyond the evidence currently available.

Fifth, the government and affected communities disagree on the cause of erosion.

This disagreement is central to the story and should not be omitted.

The MGB says dredging was not the direct cause and points to natural coastal processes and the area’s history as post-Pinatubo accretion land. (GMA Network)

Meanwhile, environmental groups and affected communities continue to question whether the scale of sediment extraction could alter coastal processes and have called for independent studies, including sediment-budget and bathymetric assessments. (Daily Tribune)


WHY IT MATTERS

For communities in Sagada and the Cordillera, this issue is important because it illustrates why environmental claims involving mining, quarrying, dredging and infrastructure projects need to be examined beyond a simple “development versus environment” narrative.

A project can have a legitimate government purpose such as flood control, river desilting or land development while still raising questions about its cumulative environmental and social impacts.

The key question is therefore not simply:

“Is dredging happening?”

It is:

“How much material is being removed, where exactly is it being removed, where does it go, and has independent scientific evidence established what effect that removal has on the coastline, fisheries and communities?”

In this case, the evidence confirms the dredging and reclamation connection, as well as real erosion and livelihood impacts, but does not establish that dredging is the sole or direct cause of Liwliwa’s erosion.


VERDICT

NEEDS CONTEXT

The Facebook post correctly identifies a real connection between Zambales sand extraction and Pasay reclamation, and it is also correct that Liwliwa has suffered serious coastal erosion and livelihood damage.

However, it goes too far by stating as fact that Pasay reclamation is destroying the Liwliwa coastline and that dredging is killing marine life and wiping out coastal communities.

The MGB has explicitly disputed dredging as the direct cause of Liwliwa’s erosion, while environmental groups and affected communities continue to call for independent scientific assessment of the possible cumulative effects of sediment extraction.

The evidence supports concern and further investigation but not the post’s definitive cause-and-effect claim.

SOURCES

  1. Philippine Reclamation Authority (PRA) – official records for the 265-hectare Pasay Harbor City and 360-hectare Pasay Reclamation and Development projects, including the Botolan, Zambales sand source. (Pea)
  2. Mines and Geosciences Bureau / DENR – assessment disputing dredging as the direct cause of Liwliwa’s coastal erosion and explaining the area’s post-Pinatubo accretion history. (GMA Network)
  3. DENR / government environmental reporting – information on coastal accretion, sediment movement and the historical development of the San Felipe coastline. (DENR)
  4. PH-EITI – documented complaint from the Zambales Ecological Network and affected communities concerning alleged sand-mining/dredging impacts and the request for independent review. (PH-EITI)
  5. Daily Tribune, September 2026 – recent reporting on Liwliwa erosion, dredging operations, DENR’s position and calls for sediment-budget, bathymetric and cumulative-impact studies. (Daily Tribune)
Climate Change","field":"name"}],"number":1,"meta_query":[[]],"paged":1,"original_offset":0,"object_ids":2626,"_bricks_query_signature":"a50b6063980e9d4e9ece8ae662f4c5be124d7846498be84582dd773e9b7d6961"}" data-original-query-vars="[]" data-page="1" data-max-pages="1" data-start="1" data-end="1">